Highly recommend this company to order all your Rochester, New York Garbage Plate Meat Hot Sauces. They ship quick, packed well, and at a reasonable price. They carry every brand available and actively seek out new brands to put in their store. At the time of writing they have 16 different sauces in their store and more coming. In addition to meat hot sauce (my blog topic) they also carry oils, vinegars, spices, hot sauce, honey, and other condiments.

Flower City Flavor Company

Coney Island Hot Dog Blend

 

Ingredients: tomato powder, ancho chili powder, porcini, smoked sea salt, onion, worcestershire, garlic, allspice, MSG, mustard powder, light brown sugar, red wine vinegar powder, kosher salt, garlic granules, onion granules, black pepper, citric acid.

Flour City Empanadas Meat Hot Sauce

 

Frank Spank

 

Ingredients: demerara sugar, paprika, sea salt, chili powder, black pepper, onion, vegetable oil, garlic, spices, and less than 1% silicon dioxide to prevent caking.

Marty Embry's Coney Spice

 

Ingredients: paprika, chili pepper, spices, salt.

Coney Mix from Fort Wayne

 

They have no picture on their website. I'll have to take my own picture some day, unfortunately this one isn't high on my list of things to buy. I'll get to it when I get to it.

Ingredients: light chili powder, onion powder, garlic powder, paprika, salt, spices.

Cincinnati-Style Chili Signature Shakes

 

Hard Times Cincinnati Chili

 

Ingredients: chili powder, cumin, red pepper, garlic, oregano, allspice, cloves, cinnamon.

MP Coney Island Seasoning

 

MP Coney Island Hot Dog Chili Meat Sauce

 

Double Play Coney Island Sauce

 

The Authentic History of Cincinnati Chili

 

My first non-food product featured on the blog. I thought it was unique. Contains 176 pages about Cincinnati Chili.

Malcom's Bonafide Chili Seasoning

 

Ingredients: salt, chili powder, sugar, cumin, garlic, ground mustard, onion, ground coriander, ground red pepper, onion flakes, lemon pepper, oregano, white pepper.

Mamma Mia Xtra Mild Chili

 

I threw this one on the list for people who need something mild. I've bought stuff from Chef Tom before. I don't know if you can really call this chili. Reading the back of the package there's no chili powder in it. this is indeed going to be mild. You combine it with meat, tomato, beans (if you want), and a cup of beer.

Ingredients: california garlic, onion, sea salt, tomato.

Seven Hills Spice Co. Cincinnati Chili

 

Ingredients: spices, chili powder, salt, onion powder, ground cinnamon, black pepper, cayenne pepper, cumin, allspice, ground bay leaf, garlic powder, apple cider vinegar powder.

No review yet.

Ingredients: water, lentils, tomato paste, onion, textured pea and bean protein, golden sugar, gluten free beer (water, millet, corn, sugar, hops, yeast), mustard (water, vinegar, mustard seeds, salt, tumeric, paprika, sunflower oil, vinegar, sea salt, spices, garlic chia seeds, vegan worcestershire sauce (water, apple cider vinegar, molasses, soy sauce, cane sugar, tamarind paste, sea salt, cornstarch, garlic, onion, clove, chili pepper), onion powder, yeast extract, natural flavor, garlic powder.

New York Style Chili Dog Sauce

No review yet.

Ingredients: dehydrated onion, tomato powder, beef base (salt, maltodextrin, dextrose, whey, HVP (corn gluten), carmel color, soybean oil, sugar, onion, natural flavors, sunflower oil (anti-caking agent), disodium insoniate, parsley, silicon dioxide, NO MEAT), salt, celery flakes and assorted spices. 

Frank's Sassy Meat Sauce

 

No review yet.

Steve T Rochester's Original Meat Sauce

02/16/2025: Update. I should have mentioned previously, but this is the soupiest of all the sauces I've tried so far. Meat and onions are definitely visible. Anyway, I've got another jar of this. I am not sure if they changed the recipe a bit or what (I doubt it since they've been around since 1963), but there's an updated list of ingredients on the jar.. maybe due to regulations on what must be labeled? I guess this gives away part of the mystery of what's in it. See below.

Ingredients: ground beef, water, onions, lard (BHT & BHA for flavor), sodium acid sulfate, spices & other natural flavors, chili powder, curry powder, xanthan gum.

Originally reviewed on 04/20/2016: Out of all the meat sauces I've tried, this one is definitely the weirdest. At first it seems kind of dull and flavorless. You can really taste the meat, but it's not salty, it's bitter, and doesn't have a lot of the flavor profile I normally associate with a meat sauce. It does have a strong flavor of something like cloves or allspice, but a lot more of that than I normally taste in a meat sauce. As you keep eating it gets spicier.

Mustard complements the sauce nicely, but the funky flavor still comes through. The flavor definitely grew on me.

Ingredients: Ground beef, water, onions, lard, sodium acid sulfate, spices, xanthan gum.

Old-Fashioned Meat Sauce

 

Meaty. Not a lot of tomato flavor in this one. Just enough. Lots of spice in this one making it a little gritty. This has a bitter aftertaste, which I can only guess it because of the cloves. Less cloves, and maybe a touch of vinegar (or cayenne pepper hot sauce which a lot of these seem to use) would make this better.

Ingredients: beef, tomatoes (tomato concentrate (water, tomato paste), salt, citric acid), water, chili powder (chili peppers, paprika, garlic, oregano, cumin, salt, less than 2% silicon dioxide added to prevent caking), sodium acid sulfate, cayenne pepper, salt, black pepper, paprika, sugar, cinnamon, cloves, thyme.